The Effect of Pre-Birth Domestic Violence

Written by Jane Evans

Many children who come into the care system, and who are subsequently adopted or go into kinship or foster care, have lived with and around domestic violence and abuse. They may have only been babies sitting in a car seat, strapped in a buggy or high chair, or held in someone’s arms as objects, fists or shoves were rained down upon the adult victim but what is clear it that they will have been affected by this. Even a baby who spends little or no time in this environment, apart from as a developing foetus will bear the long term ‘scars’ of this troubled start.

Abigail Sterne and Liz Poole in their book, Domestic Violence and Children, list some key facts which make for uncomfortable reading.

  • At least 750,000 children a year in the UK witness domestic violence……(Department of Health 2002: 16)
  • The majority of incidents occur when the children are in the same or next room (Hughes 1992: 9-11)
  • Before a woman reports domestic violence to the police, she will on average have been assaulted 35 times…….(Jaffe et al. 1986: 38 in Morley and Mullender 1994: 12)

What does this mean for a child, their adoptive parent or foster or kinship carer, teacher, pre-school worker, siblings, friends? It can mean confusion, frustration and a desire to understand which can be derailed, defeated and deflated by a daily diet of rejection and extreme behaviour.

Alarmingly, McWilliams & McKiernan, 1993 tell us that, ‘in 30% of cases of domestic violence the abuse first started during pregnancy’. Also Taft 2002 reports that ‘between 4 and 9 women in every 100 are abused during their pregnancies &/or after birth’. It can be hard to understand why pregnant women do not leave at the first sign of trouble as many of us feel we would. However, pregnancy is a time of vulnerability and often contains optimism that things will change with the arrival of a baby. Domestic abuse diminishes victims ability to think straight and they come to believe that they cannot cope alone and this can be felt even more keenly once they are pregnant as they may have been repeatedly told they will be a’ rubbish mother’.

Maternal emotional, as well as physical, messages are transmitted to the feotus so if a mother becomes fearful her heart beat alters, which can cause a reduced oxygen flow to the feotus, thus speeding up its heart rate. On a temporary basis this will be fine as it begins to prepare the developing baby’s system for the real World. Likewise feeling threatened releases necessary stress hormones such as cortisol and adrenalin which prepare the body to get us out of trouble by fleeing, fighting, freezing, befriending or flopping. Again these should flood our system for a short time, about 45 minutes, and then reduce again but repetitive fear will mean they remain at a high level for the mother and feotus, thus impacting the developing brain and system of the unborn child. This feels uncomfortable and, the developing brain becomes more reactive in the baby and on into childhood.

Ironically, the baby will then be born into an environment where the parents or carers are less available to them as they are distracted by the domestic abuse, one by maintaining and increasing it, the other by surviving it and trying to keep the baby ‘safe’. The sensitised baby is likely to be easily upset yet less responsive to being comforted and because of the chaotic home this may seldom be on offer anyway. Fast forward 3 years  to a young child who finds it hard to play with others and form friendships, who lashes out or withdraws, gets easily overwhelmed by life in general and has dramatic, long lasting outbursts, who struggles to stay focused on much for long, who does not sleep well, this list can be extensive.

The good news is that young children’s brains are much easier to reshape as through repetition it is possible to create new connections and circuits, the older the brain gets the harder this becomes but it does remain as a possibility throughout life. The fear/threat part of the brain is the only area which is resistant to this process as it has too much to lose if it can be changed as it could lead to injury of death. So understanding how to support the effects of early trauma will mean developing ways with your child of recognising and living safely and well with their strong urges to run, hit out, be still and unresponsive or to feel a compulsion to befriend everyone, especially if they seem threatening with little filtering or discrimination in order to feel safe.

Such a journey will take time, huge patience, good support, understanding and a willingness to park long held beliefs about raising children and ‘parenting’.

“It takes a parent with the inner strength of a bulldog and the heart and compassion of a golden retriever to raise a child with trauma.”

Heather T. Forbes

JE dogs

JE dogs 2

You can find Jane on her website: www.parentingposttrauma.co.uk and her blog: http://janeevansparenting.blogspot.com. Her book for child victims of domestic Violence: “How are you feeling today Baby Bear?” is scheduled to be published in February 2014.

It is not always possible to know what has triggered a child’s behaviour; it could be a sound, smell, sight, touch, even a taste, although not easy, just accept there will have been something, hence the complex behaviour.

As a survival strategy a child will be hyper sensitive to body language and facial expressions as trauma is stored in the body and brain so be observant and you can learn together.

Physical exercise, the harder the better, helps to lower levels of stress hormones so when things are beginning to escalate a run round the garden, some hard dancing or star jumps can help. Hugs are magical things but only when the child seems ready.

A kindly touch or a smile releases the soothing chemical oxytocin which plays a role in reducing anxious feelings and bonding. Some children may need touch to start very carefully as it can also trigger fear so bear this in mind. Even massaging you or a pet will be helpful.

Kindness and calmness are key along with a simple exploration of feelings everyone has when the child seems able to do this.

Join our
mailing list