Intersubjectivity

Written by Dr Jill Mack

Intersubjectivity: The key to human connection
Often children who are fostered and adopted have missed out on vital early experiences that facilitate the ability to fully connect with another and to be aware of themselves, others and the world.  Intersubjectivity is one such experience that creates a basic shared understanding between two individuals, usually the caregiver and baby. Humans are biologically wired to “coordinate their actions with others.”  Intersubjectivity is the shared, reciprocal, experience between the parent and child whereby the experience of each is having an impact on the experience of the other. For example, children experience themselves as being loved, loveable, valued, valuable, and clever whenever their parents experience them as manifesting those characteristics.

Intersubjectivity exists between conscious minds.

When intersubjectivity is present, the child develops secure attachment.

 

Both the parent and child use eye contact and facial expressions, voice tones, movement, gestures, and touch as a way of communicating with one another and showing interest and delight with one another. This creates emotionally rich times together. In a similar way, parents experience themselves as being capable and caring whenever their children experience them as manifesting those traits. It is very difficult, if not impossible, to experience oneself as possessing these traits if the important people in our lives do not experience us as having those traits.

Intersubjectivity 1Intersubjectivity 2Intersubjectivity 3

 

 

 

 

 

(By Robert Spottswood: https://ddpnetwork.org/backend/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/Intersubjectivity-Without-Words-by-Robert-Spottswood.pdf)

Imagine what a mother does when her baby cries, explores and gets angry.  The mother ideally will meet the child’s feelings and is curious out loud regarding their experience.  They are empathic to the child’s experience and verbalise what may be going on for the baby in their new or difficult experience. A lack of these apparently subtle but hugely vital experiences are shown in the still face experiment, which portrays the natural human process of attachment between a baby and caregiver.

Various things can happen which mean the parent is not available to create and co-create the early experience of intersubjectivity with the child.  When intersubjectivity is absent, particularly for a young baby, the child is not able to develop a sense of safety with his parents. The child does not have that foundation of safety from which to explore the world. Without that safety, the child does not have the platform to develop autonomy and self-reliance. The child also has difficulty learning about self, others, and the world because he has not shared in experiences with his parents. Lacking the experience of his parents’ experience of him, the child is unclear about his identity and he makes sense of the fact that his parents do not interact with him by assuming that he is bad or unlovable. Not having shared experiences of the world, the child often does not develop deep interest in the objects and events of the world.

Intersubjectivity has three components:

  • Shared emotion/affect (attunement) – is a process in which the parent and baby mutually create, match and share their affective/emotional states. This is represented in the nonverbal, bodily expression of each other’s emotions, sentiments, and desires. The attuned parent matches the affective expression of her angry baby, without being angry herself. She matches the intensity and rhythm of his voice, his gestures and movements.
  • Shared attention – Joint awareness between the child and parent. The child is fully aware of the parent and the parent is fully aware of the child. Or the parent and child are aware of the same event or object. There is no intersubjectivity if the baby is looking at the mother or a toy and the mother is looking at the TV.
  • Shared intention – The parent wants to know the child and the child wants to be known. The parent wants to enjoy being with the child and the child wants to enjoy being with the parent. The child wants to learn from the parent and the parent wants to teach the child. With joint intention, the parent and child are cooperating.

Intersubjectivity can be concordant (in sync) or discordant (out of sync).

For concordant (in sync) intersubjectivity to occur, all elements of intersubjectivity are attended to. For example, as a parent you can be fully attuned to your child and understand that they are angry because you said no to their favourite sweet before dinner. You may further be aware that this may trigger past experiences of neglect and hunger and fear of starvation. However, if there is an absence of shared attention because the child is focused on the sweet and you are focused on ensuring mealtime moves along, discordant intersubjectivity can play out.

A simple example of concordant intersubjectivity is when you and another are playing a game together. You both share the excitement of the game (the roll of the dice or play of the ball) (shared emotion), both are focused on playing the game (attention) and ideally, both are either trying to win or just playing to have fun (concordant intention). In the same example, suppose you are playing the game but one of you is playing to win the game and the other is playing just to have fun…the experience may be less than satisfying for each of you. You both share the excitement of the game (emotion) and are both paying attention to the play of the game (attention), but now you have differing intentions.

The ways intersubjectivity occurs varies across cultures. For example, in certain Indigenous American communities, nonverbal communication is so prevalent that intersubjectivity may occur regularly amongst all members of the community. A “joint cultural understanding” may develop in small, Indigenous American communities where children have grown up embedded in their community’s values, expectations, and livelihoods, learning through participation with adults rather than through intent verbal instruction—working in cohesion with one another in shared endeavours on a daily basis, learning through participation with adults rather than through intent verbal instruction and working in cohesion with one another in shared endeavours on a daily basis.

When a therapist or professional recommends working with you using Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy (DDP), he or she is often aiming to support you to create more intersubjectivity within your current relationships with you child.  The brain’s plasticity enables the initiation of new neuronal development and activity that was perhaps undeveloped from birth.  In DDP work, an intersubjective context is created through the use of PACE: Playfulness, Empathy, Acceptance, Curiosity, nonverbal attunement, and reflective dialogue.

Keeping intersubjectivity at the heart of your relationship with your child can become more challenging as children mature. As children grow, they learn more and more mechanisms to defend and manage their anxieties and fears and parents and carers can often be left wondering what their behaviour means.  They may feel harmed due to the apparent verbal, physical or emotional attacks upon them or their family experiences.  Here, Dan Hughes (the psychologist who developed DDP) explains how searching for potential meanings behind the child’s behaviours and maintaining an emphasis on intersubjectivity is crucial when managing difficult behaviours and that using a PACEful approach can help to achieve this.

http://ackerman.podbean.com/e/the-ackerman-podcast-11-intersubjective-mindfulness-with-dan-hughes-phd/

This helps us to understand why therapeutic interventions such as DDP can help develop experiences that were missed out on early in life.

The key concepts of DDP are:

  • DDP involves creating a safe setting in which the child can begin to explore, resolve, and integrate a wide range of memories, emotions, and current experiences, that are frightening, shameful, avoided or denied.
  • Safety is created by ensuring that this exploration occurs within an intersubjective context characterized by nonverbal attunement, reflective dialogue, playfulness, acceptance, curiosity, and empathy.
  • As the process unfolds, the child or young person is creating a coherent life-story which is crucial for attachment security and is a strong protective factor against psychopathology.
  • Therapeutic progress occurs within the joint activities of co-regulating affect and co-creating meaning. Dan Hughes calls this “Co-Co” therapy: co-regulation of affect is when primary caregivers (usually mother) facilitate the emotional development of their children by supporting, scaffolding, and modelling their children’s emerging emotional understanding, emotional expression, and modification of these emotions. It involves back and forth exchanges with each individual adjusting their response based on the response of the other. It is that interactive dance in which the infant and parent provide moment-to-moment feedback to each other. Co-creation of meaning is the development of meaning associated with co-.

Understanding intersubjectivity is important in aiding the use of PACE.
Here are some key reasons why PACE is important:

  • What we are asking of the child is emotionally stressful.
  • PACE engages the child intersubjectively, while lectures do not.
  • By maintaining an attitude characterized by PACE, we ensure that the child is not alone while entering that painful experience.
  • The child has developed significant symptoms and defences against the pain of their past and what it means to them, often because he or she was alone in facing it.
  • When we help the child to carry and contain the pain within them, when we co-regulate the affect with them, we are providing them with the safety needed to explore, resolve, and integrate the experience.
  • We do not facilitate safety when we support a child’s avoidance of the pain, but rather when we remain emotionally present when he is addressing and experiencing the pain.

Match the expression of emotion.  When an adult matches a child’s non-verbal expression of underlying emotion, the child is invariably able to experience the adult’s empathy for his or her experience and better regulate the underlying emotion. The adult’s emotional communication of his or her experience of the child’s emerging experience enables the child to become aware of—and deepen—his or her own experience. In other words, the child is able to see and witness their emotional self in the other.

Notice your own and your child’s non-verbal communication. They are all key signals to experience and can provide insight into what often cannot be verbalised.  Also, your child will pick up on subtleties of body language and facial expressions that may suggest you are happy to be around them or perhaps annoyed.  Eye contact suggests you are interested and want to learn about their experience.

Be truly interested and listen to your child’s experience without trying to change or make it better initially.  Be curious and wonder with them about their experiences.

Notice any particular times when trying to create intersubjective experiences is difficult or not possible.  What feelings are evoked in you during these times?

Recognise that some children do not trust the intersubjective experience and this trust will take time to develop.  Care for yourself during these times with a reminder that you are doing the best you can.

Join our
mailing list